Free Tenant Screening for Landlords: How It Actually Works

The short answer

Learn how free tenant screening for landlords works through tenant-paid PTSR models. Save $35-50 per applicant with Settl's portable screening report system.

If you manage rental properties, you've been paying for tenant screening. $35, $45, sometimes $50 per applicant — and in a competitive market, you might screen a dozen candidates before signing one lease. That's $300–$600 in screening costs for a single tenancy.

There's a different model, and it's not a gimmick: tenant-paid portable screening. Here's how it works and what you need to know before switching.

The Traditional Screening Model

In the traditional model, landlords pay for background checks through services like SmartMove (TransUnion), RentPrep, or MyRental. The landlord creates an account, sends the applicant a screening invitation, the applicant submits their info, and the landlord receives a report 24–48 hours later.

This model has problems:

• You pay for every applicant, including ones you'll clearly reject
• You wait 24–48 hours per applicant, slowing your decision timeline
• You have to manage an account with the screening vendor
• Applicants can dispute results, creating additional back-and-forth
• The cost adds up quickly across multiple vacancies per year

The Tenant-Paid Portable Screening Model

In this model, the tenant purchases their own screening report from a PTSR provider before they start applying. They share that report with every landlord they apply to. The landlord receives the report free of charge and reviews it directly.

Under Colorado's HB25-1236 (and similar emerging laws in other states), landlords who accept a PTSR cannot charge the tenant an additional screening fee. The tenant pays once; the landlord views the report at no cost.

Why This Model Works (and Why It's Legitimate)

The obvious question is: if the tenant is paying for their own screening report, couldn't they doctor it or choose a provider who gives everyone clean results?

The answer is no — because quality PTSR providers pull data directly from primary sources:

• Identity: Biometric verification against government ID databases — can't be faked
• Criminal background: Pulled directly from court and criminal databases
• Income: Pulled directly from bank accounts via Plaid — shows actual deposits, not self-reported numbers
• Employment: Pulled directly from payroll systems via Argyle — not from a resume the applicant wrote

Settl's report is signed, timestamped, and sourced directly — a tenant cannot edit their income figure or alter their background check results. The landlord is seeing primary-source data, not tenant-supplied documents.

FCRA Considerations

The Fair Credit Reporting Act governs how background check data is used in tenant screening. Under the traditional model, landlords are typically the "user" of the report and have certain FCRA obligations (adverse action notices, etc.).

In the PTSR model, the tenant is the report subject and the primary party — which shifts some of these obligations. However, landlords who use PTSR data to make screening decisions should still follow their standard adverse action procedures (notifying an applicant that a report was used in a denial decision).

When in doubt, consult a property management attorney about your specific jurisdiction's requirements.

How to Switch to Free Screening

The switch is straightforward:

• Set up a free account on the Settl landlord dashboard
• Update your rental listings to state that you accept Settl PTSRs
• When applicants contact you, direct them to settlhome.com/apply to get their report
• When they submit their application, they include their Settl verification link
• You click the link, review the full verified report, and make your decision

Your screening cost: $0. Their verification cost: $99 (first time), $39 to renew.

What About Applicants Who Don't Have a PTSR?

You don't have to require a PTSR exclusively. Many landlords use a hybrid approach: accept Settl PTSRs from applicants who have them (free to you, fast turnaround) and use a traditional screening service for applicants who don't. Over time, as PTSR adoption increases, you'll find more applicants arriving pre-screened.

In Colorado, this hybrid model is also fully compliant with HB25-1236.

Turn your savings into an approval

Settl verifies your savings and income and puts them in front of landlords as proof you can afford the place. Let the money you have saved do the talking.

Related articles