The short answer

Find out exactly what shows up on a rental background check: criminal records, evictions, credit, income. Learn what landlords see and how to prepare your application.

What Shows Up on a Rental Background Check? A Complete Guide

If you have ever been rejected from an apartment without a clear explanation, a background check may be the reason. Landlords run some form of tenant screening on nearly every applicant. Understanding what they see — and what they do not — gives you a significant advantage.

What Landlords Actually Check

Rental background checks typically combine several reports into one:

1. Credit Report

Landlords typically see your credit score and a summary of your payment history, open accounts, and any collections or charge-offs. They do not receive your full credit report (that requires your explicit consent and is governed by the FCRA).

Key items they look for:

• Credit score (most landlords want 620+; competitive markets often require 680+)
• Missed payments in the past 2 years
• Accounts in collections, especially utility or rent-related
• High credit utilization (above 50% raises flags)

2. Eviction History

This is often the most important flag. Landlord screening services like TransUnion SmartMove and Experian RentBureau pull eviction court filings — including cases where the landlord filed but the tenant left before judgment.

Key facts:

• Evictions remain on file for 7 years
• Filing alone (not just a judgment) often appears
• Some states restrict how landlords can use eviction records (Colorado, for example)

3. Criminal Background Check

Courts vary in what they report. Most rental background checks flag:

• Felony convictions (especially violence, property crimes, drug distribution)
• Misdemeanors vary by landlord and jurisdiction
• Arrests without conviction often appear but cannot legally be used in many states

4. Income and Employment Verification

Many landlords now include income verification in their screening. This may be:

• Self-reported (paystubs, bank statements) — easy to submit, hard to verify manually
• Third-party verified (Plaid bank-link, Argyle payroll) — increasingly common and far more trusted

5. Rental History

Landlords often ask for past landlord references. They may also use data from previous rental applications if you used a service that maintains a renter profile.

What Does NOT Show Up

• Medical records
• Student loan status (unless in default and in collections)
• Bankruptcies older than 10 years
• Most arrests without convictions (state laws vary)
• Social media activity

How to Prepare Before You Apply

1. Pull your own credit report. Review it at annualcreditreport.com. Dispute any errors before applying.

2. Check your eviction history. Court records are public. Search your name in your county courts portal.

3. Know your criminal background. If you have any history, research your state's laws on what landlords can legally use.

4. Pre-verify your income. Bank-verified income removes landlords' single biggest concern: can this person actually pay? Services like Settl verify your income via direct bank connection — the same method that removes all doubt.

5. Get your documents ready. Recent pay stubs, last 3 months of bank statements, current employment letter.

If Something Negative Comes Up

Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, if a landlord denies you based on a background check, they must provide an adverse action notice. You have the right to request a free copy of the report used.

You can dispute inaccurate information directly with the reporting agency.

Settl provides tenant-initiated rental readiness assessments and complies fully with the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Learn more about Settl verification.

Ready to get your Settl Verified Passport?

Verified identity, income, and stability, all in one report landlords trust. Apply anywhere, pay once.

Related articles